Guiding principles behind the establishment of UNECE regulations.

The following documents were presented and explained during the meeting. Only the most important comments are reported below.

Principles of ECE-Regulation (Japan)
The principles of this document were explained by Mr. Ishihara. They seem to be acceptable to the group.

Public consultation on outline proposals for a Regulation of the European Parliament and the Council on Advanced Safety Features and Tyres (CLEPA). The document was distributed without detailed discussion.

Time Based Warning (TBW) – For constant Tyre Pressure and CO2 reduction (BMW). Mr. Hein (BMW) introduced this proposal as a short term solution without jeopardizing middle or long term solutions.

UNECE R64: RFT & RFWS Tyre Industry Position (ETRTO) Low pressure warning of run-flat-tyres is of great concern for the tyre industry with regard to product liability (2001/95/EC). Warning thresholds need deliberate discussion.

Notes for UNECE Informal GRRF Ad-Hoc TPMS WG Meeting in Bonn on Nov. 28&29, 2007 (CLEPA). Experts from Schrader Electronics and Siemens VDO presented a first draft for a cost/benefit-analysis of TPMS. This draft is based on data from USA.

Under-inflation measurements, types, standards & rules (ISO) This document shows that depending on the TPMS technical principles, under-inflation can be detected more or less easily.

Informal document No.GRRF-62-17
The presentation which was presented during the 62nd GRRF session was shown again in order to update all delegates.

UNECE/TRANS/WP.29/GRRF – Setting up an informal group on TPMS /Terms of Reference OICA
OICA had drafted terms of reference which were discussed in detail. The group agreed on some amendments to make the text clearer and the operation principles more practicable. The amended version (Terms of reference 1.0, Status 29.11.2007) is available as document TPM-01-09. It was added that international standardisation activities shall be taken into consideration. Several questions were raised which will be matters for discussion at the next meetings. The group confirmed that in principle TPMS – requirements should be defined for all categories of vehicles but it must be sorted out if this can be done in one stage or in several stages. The situation for heavy trucks and trailers is certainly quite different from that for passenger cars.

Some experts felt that this group should develop a more.sophisticated solution from the beginning. The German government, however, is convinced that TBW is a simple solution which could be realized by the vehicle manufacturers without great problems and thus improve the situation on the road very quickly, while giving this group the opportunity to develop a more sophisticated and well balanced cost-effective solution without time pressure. The German government will therefore prepare an informal document for the next GRRF meeting to introduce TBW as a short term solution.

Public consultation on outline proposals for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on Advanced Safety Features and Tyres: background document explaining interest in electronic stability controls, tire pressure monitoring systems, and tire low rolling resistance.

The following documents were presented and explained during the meeting. Only the most important comments are reported below.

Principles of ECE-Regulation (Japan)
The principles of this document were explained by Mr. Ishihara. They seem to be acceptable to the group.

Public consultation on outline proposals for a Regulation of the European Parliament and the Council on Advanced Safety Features and Tyres (CLEPA). The document was distributed without detailed discussion.

Time Based Warning (TBW) – For constant Tyre Pressure and CO2 reduction (BMW). Mr. Hein (BMW) introduced this proposal as a short term solution without jeopardizing middle or long term solutions.

UNECE R64: RFT & RFWS Tyre Industry Position (ETRTO) Low pressure warning of run-flat-tyres is of great concern for the tyre industry with regard to product liability (2001/95/EC). Warning thresholds need deliberate discussion.

Notes for UNECE Informal GRRF Ad-Hoc TPMS WG Meeting in Bonn on Nov. 28&29, 2007 (CLEPA). Experts from Schrader Electronics and Siemens VDO presented a first draft for a cost/benefit-analysis of TPMS. This draft is based on data from USA.

Under-inflation measurements, types, standards & rules (ISO) This document shows that depending on the TPMS technical principles, under-inflation can be detected more or less easily.

Informal document No.GRRF-62-17
The presentation which was presented during the 62nd GRRF session was shown again in order to update all delegates.

UNECE/TRANS/WP.29/GRRF – Setting up an informal group on TPMS /Terms of Reference OICA
OICA had drafted terms of reference which were discussed in detail. The group agreed on some amendments to make the text clearer and the operation principles more practicable. The amended version (Terms of reference 1.0, Status 29.11.2007) is available as document TPM-01-09. It was added that international standardisation activities shall be taken into consideration. Several questions were raised which will be matters for discussion at the next meetings. The group confirmed that in principle TPMS – requirements should be defined for all categories of vehicles but it must be sorted out if this can be done in one stage or in several stages. The situation for heavy trucks and trailers is certainly quite different from that for passenger cars.

Some experts felt that this group should develop a more.sophisticated solution from the beginning. The German government, however, is convinced that TBW is a simple solution which could be realized by the vehicle manufacturers without great problems and thus improve the situation on the road very quickly, while giving this group the opportunity to develop a more sophisticated and well balanced cost-effective solution without time pressure. The German government will therefore prepare an informal document for the next GRRF meeting to introduce TBW as a short term solution.

TBW, a TPMS alternative, CO2 reduction by correct and constant tyre pressure as a first step, proposal for justification.

The following documents were presented and explained during the meeting. Only the most important comments are reported below.

Principles of ECE-Regulation (Japan)
The principles of this document were explained by Mr. Ishihara. They seem to be acceptable to the group.

Public consultation on outline proposals for a Regulation of the European Parliament and the Council on Advanced Safety Features and Tyres (CLEPA). The document was distributed without detailed discussion.

Time Based Warning (TBW) – For constant Tyre Pressure and CO2 reduction (BMW). Mr. Hein (BMW) introduced this proposal as a short term solution without jeopardizing middle or long term solutions.

UNECE R64: RFT & RFWS Tyre Industry Position (ETRTO) Low pressure warning of run-flat-tyres is of great concern for the tyre industry with regard to product liability (2001/95/EC). Warning thresholds need deliberate discussion.

Notes for UNECE Informal GRRF Ad-Hoc TPMS WG Meeting in Bonn on Nov. 28&29, 2007 (CLEPA). Experts from Schrader Electronics and Siemens VDO presented a first draft for a cost/benefit-analysis of TPMS. This draft is based on data from USA.

Under-inflation measurements, types, standards & rules (ISO) This document shows that depending on the TPMS technical principles, under-inflation can be detected more or less easily.

Informal document No.GRRF-62-17
The presentation which was presented during the 62nd GRRF session was shown again in order to update all delegates.

UNECE/TRANS/WP.29/GRRF – Setting up an informal group on TPMS /Terms of Reference OICA
OICA had drafted terms of reference which were discussed in detail. The group agreed on some amendments to make the text clearer and the operation principles more practicable. The amended version (Terms of reference 1.0, Status 29.11.2007) is available as document TPM-01-09. It was added that international standardisation activities shall be taken into consideration. Several questions were raised which will be matters for discussion at the next meetings. The group confirmed that in principle TPMS – requirements should be defined for all categories of vehicles but it must be sorted out if this can be done in one stage or in several stages. The situation for heavy trucks and trailers is certainly quite different from that for passenger cars.

Some experts felt that this group should develop a more.sophisticated solution from the beginning. The German government, however, is convinced that TBW is a simple solution which could be realized by the vehicle manufacturers without great problems and thus improve the situation on the road very quickly, while giving this group the opportunity to develop a more sophisticated and well balanced cost-effective solution without time pressure. The German government will therefore prepare an informal document for the next GRRF meeting to introduce TBW as a short term solution.

ETRTO presentation on run-flat tires and run-flat warning systems in relation to UNECE R64.

The following documents were presented and explained during the meeting. Only the most important comments are reported below.

Principles of ECE-Regulation (Japan)
The principles of this document were explained by Mr. Ishihara. They seem to be acceptable to the group.

Public consultation on outline proposals for a Regulation of the European Parliament and the Council on Advanced Safety Features and Tyres (CLEPA). The document was distributed without detailed discussion.

Time Based Warning (TBW) – For constant Tyre Pressure and CO2 reduction (BMW). Mr. Hein (BMW) introduced this proposal as a short term solution without jeopardizing middle or long term solutions.

UNECE R64: RFT & RFWS Tyre Industry Position (ETRTO) Low pressure warning of run-flat-tyres is of great concern for the tyre industry with regard to product liability (2001/95/EC). Warning thresholds need deliberate discussion.

Notes for UNECE Informal GRRF Ad-Hoc TPMS WG Meeting in Bonn on Nov. 28&29, 2007 (CLEPA). Experts from Schrader Electronics and Siemens VDO presented a first draft for a cost/benefit-analysis of TPMS. This draft is based on data from USA.

Under-inflation measurements, types, standards & rules (ISO) This document shows that depending on the TPMS technical principles, under-inflation can be detected more or less easily.

Informal document No.GRRF-62-17
The presentation which was presented during the 62nd GRRF session was shown again in order to update all delegates.

UNECE/TRANS/WP.29/GRRF – Setting up an informal group on TPMS /Terms of Reference OICA
OICA had drafted terms of reference which were discussed in detail. The group agreed on some amendments to make the text clearer and the operation principles more practicable. The amended version (Terms of reference 1.0, Status 29.11.2007) is available as document TPM-01-09. It was added that international standardisation activities shall be taken into consideration. Several questions were raised which will be matters for discussion at the next meetings. The group confirmed that in principle TPMS – requirements should be defined for all categories of vehicles but it must be sorted out if this can be done in one stage or in several stages. The situation for heavy trucks and trailers is certainly quite different from that for passenger cars.

Some experts felt that this group should develop a more.sophisticated solution from the beginning. The German government, however, is convinced that TBW is a simple solution which could be realized by the vehicle manufacturers without great problems and thus improve the situation on the road very quickly, while giving this group the opportunity to develop a more sophisticated and well balanced cost-effective solution without time pressure. The German government will therefore prepare an informal document for the next GRRF meeting to introduce TBW as a short term solution.

Presentation providing background and justifications for global TPMS regulation.

The following documents were presented and explained during the meeting. Only the most important comments are reported below.

Principles of ECE-Regulation (Japan)
The principles of this document were explained by Mr. Ishihara. They seem to be acceptable to the group.

Public consultation on outline proposals for a Regulation of the European Parliament and the Council on Advanced Safety Features and Tyres (CLEPA). The document was distributed without detailed discussion.

Time Based Warning (TBW) – For constant Tyre Pressure and CO2 reduction (BMW). Mr. Hein (BMW) introduced this proposal as a short term solution without jeopardizing middle or long term solutions.

UNECE R64: RFT & RFWS Tyre Industry Position (ETRTO) Low pressure warning of run-flat-tyres is of great concern for the tyre industry with regard to product liability (2001/95/EC). Warning thresholds need deliberate discussion.

Notes for UNECE Informal GRRF Ad-Hoc TPMS WG Meeting in Bonn on Nov. 28&29, 2007 (CLEPA). Experts from Schrader Electronics and Siemens VDO presented a first draft for a cost/benefit-analysis of TPMS. This draft is based on data from USA.

Under-inflation measurements, types, standards & rules (ISO) This document shows that depending on the TPMS technical principles, under-inflation can be detected more or less easily.

Informal document No.GRRF-62-17
The presentation which was presented during the 62nd GRRF session was shown again in order to update all delegates.

UNECE/TRANS/WP.29/GRRF – Setting up an informal group on TPMS /Terms of Reference OICA
OICA had drafted terms of reference which were discussed in detail. The group agreed on some amendments to make the text clearer and the operation principles more practicable. The amended version (Terms of reference 1.0, Status 29.11.2007) is available as document TPM-01-09. It was added that international standardisation activities shall be taken into consideration. Several questions were raised which will be matters for discussion at the next meetings. The group confirmed that in principle TPMS – requirements should be defined for all categories of vehicles but it must be sorted out if this can be done in one stage or in several stages. The situation for heavy trucks and trailers is certainly quite different from that for passenger cars.

Some experts felt that this group should develop a more.sophisticated solution from the beginning. The German government, however, is convinced that TBW is a simple solution which could be realized by the vehicle manufacturers without great problems and thus improve the situation on the road very quickly, while giving this group the opportunity to develop a more sophisticated and well balanced cost-effective solution without time pressure. The German government will therefore prepare an informal document for the next GRRF meeting to introduce TBW as a short term solution.

The following documents were presented and explained during the meeting. Only the most important comments are reported below.

Principles of ECE-Regulation (Japan)
The principles of this document were explained by Mr. Ishihara. They seem to be acceptable to the group.

Public consultation on outline proposals for a Regulation of the European Parliament and the Council on Advanced Safety Features and Tyres (CLEPA). The document was distributed without detailed discussion.

Time Based Warning (TBW) – For constant Tyre Pressure and CO2 reduction (BMW). Mr. Hein (BMW) introduced this proposal as a short term solution without jeopardizing middle or long term solutions.

UNECE R64: RFT & RFWS Tyre Industry Position (ETRTO) Low pressure warning of run-flat-tyres is of great concern for the tyre industry with regard to product liability (2001/95/EC). Warning thresholds need deliberate discussion.

Notes for UNECE Informal GRRF Ad-Hoc TPMS WG Meeting in Bonn on Nov. 28&29, 2007 (CLEPA). Experts from Schrader Electronics and Siemens VDO presented a first draft for a cost/benefit-analysis of TPMS. This draft is based on data from USA.

Under-inflation measurements, types, standards & rules (ISO) This document shows that depending on the TPMS technical principles, under-inflation can be detected more or less easily.

Informal document No.GRRF-62-17
The presentation which was presented during the 62nd GRRF session was shown again in order to update all delegates.

UNECE/TRANS/WP.29/GRRF – Setting up an informal group on TPMS /Terms of Reference OICA
OICA had drafted terms of reference which were discussed in detail. The group agreed on some amendments to make the text clearer and the operation principles more practicable. The amended version (Terms of reference 1.0, Status 29.11.2007) is available as document TPM-01-09. It was added that international standardisation activities shall be taken into consideration. Several questions were raised which will be matters for discussion at the next meetings. The group confirmed that in principle TPMS – requirements should be defined for all categories of vehicles but it must be sorted out if this can be done in one stage or in several stages. The situation for heavy trucks and trailers is certainly quite different from that for passenger cars.

Some experts felt that this group should develop a more.sophisticated solution from the beginning. The German government, however, is convinced that TBW is a simple solution which could be realized by the vehicle manufacturers without great problems and thus improve the situation on the road very quickly, while giving this group the opportunity to develop a more sophisticated and well balanced cost-effective solution without time pressure. The German government will therefore prepare an informal document for the next GRRF meeting to introduce TBW as a short term solution.

TPMS Motivations; Principles of tire pressure monitoring systems (TPMS); Impact Factors for Direct TPMS; Impact Factors for Indirect TPMS; CO2 and TPMS; Effect on other regulations

An agenda could not be distributed before the meeting but the chairman had prepared a draft in document TPMS-01-07. OICA had sent draft terms of reference (doc. TPM-01-08) which were used as a basis for the discussion.

The following documents were presented and explained during the meeting. Only the most important comments are reported below.

Principles of ECE-Regulation (Japan)
The principles of this document were explained by Mr. Ishihara. They seem to be acceptable to the group.

Public consultation on outline proposals for a Regulation of the European Parliament and the Council on Advanced Safety Features and Tyres (CLEPA). The document was distributed without detailed discussion.

Time Based Warning (TBW) – For constant Tyre Pressure and CO2 reduction (BMW). Mr. Hein (BMW) introduced this proposal as a short term solution without jeopardizing middle or long term solutions.

UNECE R64: RFT & RFWS Tyre Industry Position (ETRTO) Low pressure warning of run-flat-tyres is of great concern for the tyre industry with regard to product liability (2001/95/EC). Warning thresholds need deliberate discussion.

Notes for UNECE Informal GRRF Ad-Hoc TPMS WG Meeting in Bonn on Nov. 28&29, 2007 (CLEPA). Experts from Schrader Electronics and Siemens VDO presented a first draft for a cost/benefit-analysis of TPMS. This draft is based on data from USA.

Under-inflation measurements, types, standards & rules (ISO) This document shows that depending on the TPMS technical principles, under-inflation can be detected more or less easily.

Informal document No.GRRF-62-17
The presentation which was presented during the 62nd GRRF session was shown again in order to update all delegates.

UNECE/TRANS/WP.29/GRRF – Setting up an informal group on TPMS /Terms of Reference OICA
OICA had drafted terms of reference which were discussed in detail. The group agreed on some amendments to make the text clearer and the operation principles more practicable. The amended version (Terms of reference 1.0, Status 29.11.2007) is available as document TPM-01-09. It was added that international standardisation activities shall be taken into consideration. Several questions were raised which will be matters for discussion at the next meetings. The group confirmed that in principle TPMS – requirements should be defined for all categories of vehicles but it must be sorted out if this can be done in one stage or in several stages. The situation for heavy trucks and trailers is certainly quite different from that for passenger cars.

Some experts felt that this group should develop a more.sophisticated solution from the beginning. The German government, however, is convinced that TBW is a simple solution which could be realized by the vehicle manufacturers without great problems and thus improve the situation on the road very quickly, while giving this group the opportunity to develop a more sophisticated and well balanced cost-effective solution without time pressure. The German government will therefore prepare an informal document for the next GRRF meeting to introduce TBW as a short term solution.

OICA proposal on terms of reference for the TPM informal group.

An agenda could not be distributed before the meeting but the chairman had prepared a draft in document TPMS-01-07. OICA had sent draft terms of reference (doc. TPM-01-08) which were used as a basis for the discussion.

The following documents were presented and explained during the meeting. Only the most important comments are reported below.

Principles of ECE-Regulation (Japan)
The principles of this document were explained by Mr. Ishihara. They seem to be acceptable to the group.

Public consultation on outline proposals for a Regulation of the European Parliament and the Council on Advanced Safety Features and Tyres (CLEPA). The document was distributed without detailed discussion.

Time Based Warning (TBW) – For constant Tyre Pressure and CO2 reduction (BMW). Mr. Hein (BMW) introduced this proposal as a short term solution without jeopardizing middle or long term solutions.

UNECE R64: RFT & RFWS Tyre Industry Position (ETRTO) Low pressure warning of run-flat-tyres is of great concern for the tyre industry with regard to product liability (2001/95/EC). Warning thresholds need deliberate discussion.

Notes for UNECE Informal GRRF Ad-Hoc TPMS WG Meeting in Bonn on Nov. 28&29, 2007 (CLEPA). Experts from Schrader Electronics and Siemens VDO presented a first draft for a cost/benefit-analysis of TPMS. This draft is based on data from USA.

Under-inflation measurements, types, standards & rules (ISO) This document shows that depending on the TPMS technical principles, under-inflation can be detected more or less easily.

Informal document No.GRRF-62-17
The presentation which was presented during the 62nd GRRF session was shown again in order to update all delegates.

UNECE/TRANS/WP.29/GRRF – Setting up an informal group on TPMS /Terms of Reference OICA
OICA had drafted terms of reference which were discussed in detail. The group agreed on some amendments to make the text clearer and the operation principles more practicable. The amended version (Terms of reference 1.0, Status 29.11.2007) is available as document TPM-01-09. It was added that international standardisation activities shall be taken into consideration. Several questions were raised which will be matters for discussion at the next meetings. The group confirmed that in principle TPMS – requirements should be defined for all categories of vehicles but it must be sorted out if this can be done in one stage or in several stages. The situation for heavy trucks and trailers is certainly quite different from that for passenger cars.

Some experts felt that this group should develop a more.sophisticated solution from the beginning. The German government, however, is convinced that TBW is a simple solution which could be realized by the vehicle manufacturers without great problems and thus improve the situation on the road very quickly, while giving this group the opportunity to develop a more sophisticated and well balanced cost-effective solution without time pressure. The German government will therefore prepare an informal document for the next GRRF meeting to introduce TBW as a short term solution.

Draft guidelines for the scope and mandate of the informal working group on tire pressure monitoring systems, based upon an original proposal prepared by OICA.

The following documents were presented and explained during the meeting. Only the most important comments are reported below.

Principles of ECE-Regulation (Japan)
The principles of this document were explained by Mr. Ishihara. They seem to be acceptable to the group.

Public consultation on outline proposals for a Regulation of the European Parliament and the Council on Advanced Safety Features and Tyres (CLEPA). The document was distributed without detailed discussion.

Time Based Warning (TBW) – For constant Tyre Pressure and CO2 reduction (BMW). Mr. Hein (BMW) introduced this proposal as a short term solution without jeopardizing middle or long term solutions.

UNECE R64: RFT & RFWS Tyre Industry Position (ETRTO) Low pressure warning of run-flat-tyres is of great concern for the tyre industry with regard to product liability (2001/95/EC). Warning thresholds need deliberate discussion.

Notes for UNECE Informal GRRF Ad-Hoc TPMS WG Meeting in Bonn on Nov. 28&29, 2007 (CLEPA). Experts from Schrader Electronics and Siemens VDO presented a first draft for a cost/benefit-analysis of TPMS. This draft is based on data from USA.

Under-inflation measurements, types, standards & rules (ISO) This document shows that depending on the TPMS technical principles, under-inflation can be detected more or less easily.

Informal document No.GRRF-62-17
The presentation which was presented during the 62nd GRRF session was shown again in order to update all delegates.

UNECE/TRANS/WP.29/GRRF – Setting up an informal group on TPMS /Terms of Reference OICA
OICA had drafted terms of reference which were discussed in detail. The group agreed on some amendments to make the text clearer and the operation principles more practicable. The amended version (Terms of reference 1.0, Status 29.11.2007) is available as document TPM-01-09. It was added that international standardisation activities shall be taken into consideration. Several questions were raised which will be matters for discussion at the next meetings. The group confirmed that in principle TPMS – requirements should be defined for all categories of vehicles but it must be sorted out if this can be done in one stage or in several stages. The situation for heavy trucks and trailers is certainly quite different from that for passenger cars.

Some experts felt that this group should develop a more.sophisticated solution from the beginning. The German government, however, is convinced that TBW is a simple solution which could be realized by the vehicle manufacturers without great problems and thus improve the situation on the road very quickly, while giving this group the opportunity to develop a more sophisticated and well balanced cost-effective solution without time pressure. The German government will therefore prepare an informal document for the next GRRF meeting to introduce TBW as a short term solution.

As defined in the terms of reference the first task will be to identify the potential for improvement of road safety and fuel efficiency. In the opinion of some experts, besides safety, fuel efficiency or environmental protection has the highest priority.

In order to identify the potential for improvement it is necessary to know the present situation on the road, that means figures and data about the number of vehicles which are driven with under-inflated tyres, the number of under-inflated tyres on each vehicle and the degree of under-inflation.

It was decided to establish a task force for the the collection of such data. Mr. Wim Verhoeve from CLEPA (w.verhoeve@clepa.be) agreed to be chairman of the task force. Members will be experts from OICA, CLEPA, ETRTO and governments, Japan will be included by e-mail contact.

The task force should have its first meeting at the beginning of 2008, in any case before the next meeting of this group in order to be able to present first results for the next meeting.

The report was accepted without comments.

Summary of the report and pursuant discussion of the progress of the informal group on tire pressure monitoring systems.

A report of the secretary about the discussion of TPMS during the 63rd GRRF meeting is available on the GRRF website as document TPM-01-11. OICA reported that the time pressure from the GRRF chairman to receive a final draft regulation on TPMS has been reduced.