| Traumatic Brain Injury Risk Functions for Frontal Crash Assessment |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-21 |
|
Document presents development of traumatic brain injury risk functions for frontal crash assessment. Brain strain-based injury risk functions were developed using human and non-human primate injury data from experimental studies, calculated using finite element brain models. Kinematics-based injury risk functions were derived by converting strain-based functions using correlations with head rotational kinematics metrics. Injury risk functions were developed for each kinematics-based metric selected through correlation analysis with maximum principal strain in brain tissue. |
| Submitted by: JARI and JAMA |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 15 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Equitable Occupant Protection: Minutes of the 17th (October 2026) session |
| Reference Number: EqOP-17-02 |
|
Draft minutes of the 17th meeting of the IWG EqOP held on 14 October 2026. The IWG’s strategic objective is to achieve more equitable and robust occupant protection for a diverse population through inclusive regulations and protection strategies that reduce injury risk below a tolerable threshold for as many occupants as possible. The priorities endorsed by GRSP remain rear impact protection, frontal impact restraint systems, and the assessment of injury types that are currently insufficiently addressed, particularly brain, soft-tissue neck, and lower-extremity injuries. The Chairs reviewed progress of task forces and introduced the proposed theme of the Tokyo workshop: robustness assessment of occupant protection. |
| Submitted by: EqOP |
| Meeting Sessions: 17th EqOP session (14 Oct) |
| Document date: 13 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Advantages of HBMs compared to ATDs |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-08 |
|
Document compares human body model (HBM) capabilities with anthropomorphic test device (ATD) limitations. HBMs enable assessment at lower impact speeds, evaluation of older occupants with age-dependent material properties, checking belt fit across multiple anthropometries, assessment of restraint system interaction with different body shapes, evaluation of varying postures including non-upright hip angles, consideration of pre-crash phase effects on in-crash phase, and addressing injury types limited by ATD sensor availability and biofidelity. HBMs can be used omnidirectionally if validated, whereas ATDs are limited to design range and single loading direction. Harmonization work is needed for active HBMs, anthropometric agreement, belt fit criteria, and spine curvature validation. |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 12 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: UN Regulation No. 137 | Restraint System in Frontal Impact and WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Submarining Evaluation in HBM- and ATD-Simulations with Nearest Node-Indicator |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-23 |
|
A study of methods to evaluate submarining using human body models and anthropomorphic test devices. The research tested 600 simulations across six environments with one human body model and three anthropomorphic test devices, integrating 20 different indicator definitions. A distance-based nearest node dynamic indicator emerged as most promising. The indicator is purely kinematic, time-resolved, automated, and configurable, depending only on node coordinates without force or sensor outputs. It was subsequently tested and extended to additional anthropometries. The indicator detects submarining effectively and can be combined with complementary criteria. |
| Submitted by: BMW |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 04 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| EqOP informal group poll results on robustness |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-22 |
|
Document presents results from an open text poll and ranking polls conducted during the EqOP-Japan workshop on robustness assessment. Participants submitted ideas for robustness assessment addressing human body model evaluation, injury types, protection principles, and regulatory framework considerations. Topics ranked include brain injuries, submarining, lower extremities, chest injuries, soft tissue neck injuries, abdominal injuries, and assessment parameters such as lower test speeds, more anthropometries, rear row assessment, and seat position variations. |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 06 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Axonal Tolerance for Uniaxial Stretching |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-20 |
|
Study on axonal injury from uniaxial stretching in rat nerve cells. Experiments measured formation of axonal swellings and bulbs following stretching at various strain and strain rate conditions. Results show axonal injury observed at strain levels of 0.18 and above. Under 0.15 strain, injury percentage significantly increased at strain rates over 50 s⁻¹. Under 0.20 strain, injury percentage significantly increased at strain rates over 30 s⁻¹. Injury tolerance for axonal injury assessment should be determined based on combination of strain and strain rate. |
| Submitted by: NTSEL |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 05 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Fond Passengers in Passenger Cars |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-18 |
|
Analysis of second row occupant injuries in passenger cars using GIDAS data from 2000–2025. Second row occupants constitute approximately 11% of all car occupants and contribute approximately 9% to MAIS2+ and slightly more to MAIS3+ injured occupants. Injury severity is higher in the second row left seat. Neck injuries, particularly whiplash, are the most common low-severity injuries, while upper-body injuries are most significant across all severity levels. Head and face injuries from seat contact are the most common injury-causing mechanism at all crash severities. The document recommends load cases should include second row occupation with 5% and 50% anthropomorphic test devices. |
| Submitted by: CLEPA |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 05 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: UN Regulation No. 21 | Interior Fittings, UN Regulation No. 137 | Restraint System in Frontal Impact, and WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Effect of Seat Condition on Abdominal Injuries to Vehicle Occupants in Frontal Impact |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-13 |
|
Study investigating the correlation between downward movement conditions of the seat and lap belt movement from the iliac crests of a human occupant in the front passenger seat during frontal impact. Simulations were conducted using an AM50 THUMS human model under two seat conditions: vertical downward movement of 150 mm, and 150 mm vertical downward movement combined with forward rotation. Results show the lap belt detached from both iliac crests during lean forward seat movement, whereas it detached from only one iliac crest during vertical movement. Abdominal injuries can be caused by downward seat movement together with forward rotation during frontal impacts. |
| Submitted by: NTSEL |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 04 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Towards a Real-World Frontal Crash Assessment Matrix: From Field Data to Representative Crash and Occupant Conditions |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-12 |
|
Analysis of field data from 3,847 belted drivers in frontal car-to-car crashes to develop a real-world frontal crash assessment matrix. Field data showed injury distribution followed exposure distribution across stature and weight, no significant injury-risk differences across longitudinal seat positions or age groups, and approximately 75% of AIS2+ injuries occurred at energy equivalent speed below 40 km/h. The assessment matrix identifies severity-specific protection targets and crash configurations representative of real-world exposure. The approach combines crash, occupant and seating variation with human body model simulations to evaluate restraint system robustness across real-world variability. |
| Submitted by: Autoliv |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 04 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Inspiration from the approach in WP.29 when regulating DCAS and ADS Safety management system, safety case, safety concept |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-11 |
|
The document describes WP.29’s approach to regulating Driver Control Assistance Systems and Automated Driving Systems. It outlines safety management system requirements including safety policy, risk management, assurance and promotion; safety case requirements for structured documentation demonstrating ADS compliance and freedom from unreasonable risk; and safety concept requirements for risk identification, hazard analysis, ODD compatibility and occupant protection. Testing and verification encompasses virtual testing using simulation toolchains, track testing and real-world testing. Virtual toolchain validation establishes credibility before use. In-service monitoring and reporting requires manufacturers to monitor ADS performance post-deployment and report significant incidents to authorities. |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 04 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: UN Regulation No. 171 | Driver-Control Assistance Systems (DCAS), WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection, and UN Regulation No. 185 | Approval of vehicles with regard to their Automated Driving Systems |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Complementary Roles of ATDs & HBMs in Frontal Impact Assessment |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-10 |
|
Presentation on the complementary roles of Anthropomorphic Test Devices (ATDs) and Human Body Models (HBMs) in frontal impact assessment. ATDs provide standardized physical evidence at defined reference conditions based on fixed anthropometries, while HBMs can represent population variability through morphable anthropometry. HBMs extend assessment to human and crash variability that standardized ATD tests cannot practically cover, including occupant size variants, seat positions, postures, and crash severities. Neither tool is a universal substitute for the other; complementary capabilities improve robustness and confidence in real-world occupant protection performance. |
| Submitted by: Autoliv |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 04 Oct 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Human Body Models for Virtual Testing: Expectations and Challenges |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-09 |
|
Presentation on human body models (HBMs) for virtual testing, addressing their advantages over anthropomorphic test devices (ATDs) in assessing occupant diversity, body regions, and injury criteria. Discusses challenges including harmonization of anthropometry and posture, biofidelity qualification variability, and injury assessment methodology. Proposes stepwise implementation with minimum harmonization requirements and development of HBM-specific injury risk curves for consistent application across different anthropometries. |
| Submitted by: JAMA |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 06 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| EqOP workshop on frontal impact - Results |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-07 |
|
Results from a workshop on frontal impact robustness held in Tokyo, Japan on 4-6 November 2026. The workshop established a robustness concept: the vehicle’s ability to ensure effective protection for occupants across a representative range of characteristics (taking into account variations such as differences in shape, sex, weight and age), in relevant vehicle settings, and in representative real-world collisions (up to current regulatory severity levels). Human Body Models (HBMs) are noted as a promising complementary tool for evaluating robustness alongside ATD testing. The workshop ranked injury types by priority, including brain injuries, submarining, neck, chest, abdomen, lower extremities, and rear seat row protection. An action plan was developed to address brain injuries, submarining, rear seat row assessment, and robustness assessment methodology. |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 10 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: UN Regulation No. 12 | Steering Mechanism Impact Protection, UN Regulation No. 14 | Safety-Belt and ISOFIX Anchorages, UN Regulation No. 16 | Safety belts and related systems, UN Regulation No. 21 | Interior Fittings, UN Regulation No. 94 | Occupant Protection in Frontal Collisions, UN Regulation No. 137 | Restraint System in Frontal Impact, WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection, and UN Regulation No. 173 | Installation of safety belts, restraint systems, child restraint systems, ISOFIX child restraint systems and i-Size child restraint systems |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| EqOP workshop on frontal impact - Robustness |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-05 |
|
Workshop participants agreed on a concept of robustness as the vehicle’s ability to ensure effective protection for occupants across a representative range of characteristics including variations in body shape, sex, weight and age in relevant vehicle settings and in representative real-world collisions up to current regulatory severity levels. Current regulations can identify clearly inferior systems but do not encourage robustness as defined. |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 10 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Equitable Occupant Protection Workshop 5 - Introduction and Recap |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-04 |
|
Workshop on equitable occupant protection addressing frontal impact safety. The document summarizes consensus from the 2025 Graz workshop on equity issues in frontal crashes, including higher injury risks for females in lower-speed crashes and at specific injury severity levels, age-dependent fatality risk variations, and injury pattern differences across body regions. Hypotheses for equity issues include occupant physiological characteristics, seatbelt and seat interaction, airbag interaction, and varying injury tolerances with age and sex. The Tokyo workshop aims to develop conceptual ideas for assessing robustness of occupant protection across human and crash-condition variability, define robustness, identify regulatory concepts to address equity issues, establish a roadmap of regulatory solutions, and create an action plan for highest-priority issues. |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 10 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: GTR No. 7 | Head Restraints, UN Regulation No. 12 | Steering Mechanism Impact Protection, UN Regulation No. 14 | Safety-Belt and ISOFIX Anchorages, UN Regulation No. 16 | Safety belts and related systems, UN Regulation No. 17 | Strength of Seats, Anchorages, and Head Restraints, UN Regulation No. 21 | Interior Fittings, UN Regulation No. 25 | Head Restraints, UN Regulation No. 32 | Vehicle Behavior in Rear-End Collisions, UN Regulation No. 94 | Occupant Protection in Frontal Collisions, UN Regulation No. 95 | Occupant Protection in Lateral Collisions, GTR No. 14 | Pole Side Impact Protection (PSI), UN Regulation No. 135 | Pole side-impact protection, UN Regulation No. 137 | Restraint System in Frontal Impact, and WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| EqOP Frontal Impact Workshops: Agenda for the 5th (November 2026) session |
| Reference Number: EqOP-WS-05-01-Rev.5 |
|
The workshop on frontal impact assessment in Tokyo, 4-6 November 2026, will address robustness, defined as the vehicle’s ability to protect occupants of varying body height, weight, shape, and seating position in real-world relevant collisions by maintaining structural integrity and effective safety systems so that the risk of injury is minimized for all types of people. The agenda includes review of relevant regulations, clarification of roles of ATDs and HBMs, and conceptual ideas for future regulatory upgrades addressing brain injury, soft tissue neck injury, lower leg injury, thorax injury, submarining, abdominal loading, and lower severity collisions. The workshop will develop an HBM-based robustness assessment matrix to complement current ATD-based requirements. |
| Meeting Sessions: 5th EqOP-WS session (4-6 Nov) |
| Document date: 10 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Frontal Impact Workshop Priorities Table |
| Reference Number: EqOP-TF3-17-03-Rev.1 |
| Meeting Sessions: 17th EqOP-TF3 session (15 Oct) |
| Document date: 02 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Human Body Model Readiness Roadmap |
| Reference Number: EqOP-TF3-17-02 |
| Meeting Sessions: 17th EqOP-TF3 session (15 Oct) |
| Document date: 01 Nov 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| EqOP Progress Dashboard (September 2026) |
| Reference Number: EqOP-00 |
| Document date: 16 Oct 26 |
| Relevant to: WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
| Orientation slides for the 17th EqOP informal group session |
| Reference Number: EqOP-17-03 |
|
The informal working group on Equitable Occupant Protection reviewed the status of five task forces addressing rear-end impact, virtual crash testing, frontal impact and restraint systems, and assessment of currently not considered injury types with high frequency and risk of permanent medical impairment. The group discussed robustness assessment for occupant protection, defined as the vehicle’s ability to protect occupants with variation of body height, weight, shape, physical constitution, and age in real-world relevant collisions. An upcoming workshop in Tokyo will develop conceptual ideas for assessing robustness by evaluating performance over a matrix of human and crash-condition variability, complementing current requirement-specific assessments based on anthropomorphic test devices, with status reports due December 2026 and final report December 2027. |
| Meeting Sessions: 17th EqOP session (14 Oct) |
| Document date: 14 Oct 26 |
| Relevant to: UN Regulation No. 14 | Safety-Belt and ISOFIX Anchorages, UN Regulation No. 16 | Safety belts and related systems, UN Regulation No. 94 | Occupant Protection in Frontal Collisions, UN Regulation No. 137 | Restraint System in Frontal Impact, and WP.29 Discussion Topic | Equitable Occupant Protection |
| Click here to view the full document file |
No matching documents.